puzzled once again

Today was one of those unique days for Detroit sports where every team was in action of sorts. The Tigers pummeled the Twins 18-1, while the Pistons and Red Wings both lost playoff games. And then theres the Lions who were drafting players in hopes for a better future.

But yet once again, it seems that GM Matt Millen made a mistake in his first round pick. With Matt Leinart having slipped to the spot where the Lions were picking (Detroit had the ninth pick) Millen decided to pass on the proven winner and select Florida State outside linebacker Ernie Sims. Wow Sims has been compared to Derrick Brooks as a player it seems like he is yet another risky selection.

According to various scouting reports on Sims, it is noted that he likes to play wild and with havoc - something that could lead to some dumb penalties. But it looks like he could also put a hurting on the opposition. Also I've read that Sims has been injured quite a bit - something definitely not helpful - especially with the Lions always having someone on their defense hurt (i.e Teddy Lehman, Boss Bailey). Lastly I read on a website that Sims has been charged with domestic battery and resisting arrest. Before the draft Lions coach Marinelli stressed he wanted someone with good character.

Hopefully this pick pans and out and improves the Lions defense but I still think going with Leinart would have been the best case.
Despite the Lions having signed 8 bajillion quarterbacks in the offseason, Leinart is a proven winner and comes from a successful program at USC. He only lost twice as a starter after taking over for Carson Palmer (who was drafted by the Bengals)
Second, Leinart could have sat behind Jon Kitna - just like Palmer did while he was at Cincy. Look at what Palmer has done to help ressurrect the Bengals. He made them a playoff team that coulda done damage had he not got hurt in their playoff game against the Steelers.

I was also surprised to see the Lions pass on USC tailback LenDale White, who was around for their pick in the second round. I however was happy with the selection of Wisconsin tailback Brian Calhoun and it seems like he will fit in well with Mike Martz's offense.

Below is the story the associated press ran when Sims declared for the draft early
Seminole linebacker entering NFL draft early

By BRENT KALLESTAD, Associated Press Writer
January 9, 2006

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- Worried about a career-ending injury, Florida State linebacker Ernie Sims will give up his final year of eligibility and enter the NFL draft.

Sims became the second Florida State defensive player in two weeks to say he is leaving school early for a shot at the pros. He joins cornerback Antonio Cromartie, who missed the 2005 season with a knee injury.

ADVERTISEMENT


"It's been my dream since I've been a little kid," Sims said. "Not a lot of people get a chance to play in the NFL."

Sims, accompanied to Monday's news conference by his parents and agent Todd France, said the NFL has projected him as an early second-round pick.

A speedy, undersized junior, he's listed at 6-foot and 220 pounds. Sims made 198 tackles in his three seasons, two as a starter. He finished fourth on the team with 70 stops this year, including four in Florida State's 26-23 Orange Bowl loss last week to Penn State.

Sims' production fell off last season from a sparkling sophomore year. Many opponents, however, designed their offenses to avoid him, said FSU linebacker coach Kevin Steele, a one-time NFL assistant.

Sims left Monday for Arizona to begin training for next month's combine in Indianapolis, where NFL scouts measure, time and test prospects. He hopes to add 5 or 6 pounds before the combine.

Sims has been troubled by nagging injuries as well as concussions, missing a game at Duke in October.

"If I did come back, I would risk not being able to play again," he said. "I might get injured."

Steele believes Sims' worries about concussions won't affect his draft standing.

"It's not off the chart where it's going to be in that category," Steele said.

Sims was an honorable mention Atlantic Coast Conference pick this year. He acknowledged that his college career wasn't what he had hoped.

"I didn't leave a statement like I really wanted to," he said.

He is 40 hours short of earning a degree, but said he will finish school during the offseasons.